Web750 Support Articles and How-to guides:


Guide for Choosing the Right Linux Server OS: Debian vs Ubuntu vs RHEL vs SUSE



Introduction


In the expansive universe of server operating systems (OS), Linux is a paragon of efficiency, flexibility, and security. Its reputation as a powerhouse for server management is well-deserved, with its deployment spanning from the servers of small businesses to the foundational technology behind massive cloud and internet services.


The core of Linux's appeal lies in its open-source nature, which has led to the development of a wide array of distributions, each designed to cater to different needs and preferences.


Choosing the suitable Linux distribution for server use is critical, transcending mere preference to significantly impact servers' operational efficacy, security, and manageability.


The Importance of Choosing the Right Linux Server OS


The selection of the most suitable Linux server OS is paramount. Each distribution presents a unique combination of features, community support, and software ecosystems, making some more apt for specific tasks than others.


Considerations such as system stability, the longevity of support, security protocols, and the availability of software packages are pivotal in determining a distribution's appropriateness for server deployment.


Moreover, this decision influences future scalability, maintenance requirements, and compatibility with existing systems, necessitating a comprehensive evaluation to ensure alignment with both business objectives and technical needs.


This guide compares four leading Linux server operating systems: Debian, Ubuntu, Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL), and SUSE.


Understanding Linux Server OS


Definition of a Server OS


A server operating system (OS) is a specialized software designed to manage hardware resources and provide a platform for running server-specific software that offers client services over a network.


This type of OS is engineered to handle scalability, reliability, and the efficient allocation of network resources, enabling it to process numerous simultaneous requests without degrading performance.


Role and Importance in Enterprise Environments


In enterprise environments, the server OS plays a crucial role. It is the bedrock for running essential business applications and services like databases, web services, and enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems.


The choice of server OS directly impacts the system's stability, security profile, and capability to scale in response to the needs of the business. Consequently, the server OS is foundational to the reliability of the IT infrastructure, affecting operational efficiency and the uninterrupted flow of business processes.


Key Features to Look for in a Server OS


Selecting a Linux server OS for enterprise use involves considering several key features:


System Stability: Essential for ensuring uninterrupted services and operations.


Security Measures: Critical for protecting data and services from unauthorized access and other cyber threats.


Virtualization Support: Enables efficient resource utilization and deployment of multiple virtual servers or VMs on a single physical server.


Hardware and Software Compatibility: Ensures the OS can work seamlessly with existing IT infrastructure.


Updates and Technical Support: Regular updates and reliable support are vital for addressing vulnerabilities and ensuring the OS remains effective against emerging threats.


Software Repositories and Package Management: A rich set of software packages and an efficient management system simplify the installation and maintenance of server applications.


Community and Commercial Support: A solid or available commercial support can provide invaluable assistance and resources.


These features are integral to a Linux server OS's ability to meet and adapt to the dynamic requirements of enterprise environments, ensuring high performance, security, and scalability.


Debian


Overview of Debian


Debian is a free and open-source server and Desktop operating system or OS that uses the Linux kernel and contains software from the GNU project. It is renowned for its commitment to free software principles, robustness, and vast software repositories.


A community of volunteers worldwide develops Debian and serves as a foundation for numerous other Linux distributions, including Ubuntu.


History and Development


Debian Linux OS was founded in 1993 by Ian Murdock to create a completely free and collaborative Linux distribution. Over the years, it has become one of the most respected and widely used Linux distributions, known for its strict adherence to the open-source philosophy, stability, and extensive testing process.


Target Audience and Typical Use Cases


Debian is favored by experienced Linux users and system administrators for its stability and reliability. It is commonly used in server environments, ranging from web hosting to cloud infrastructure, owing to its solid performance and security features. Debian is famous for desktop users seeking a stable and comprehensive operating system.


Key Features


Stability and Reliability: Debian's release cycle is not set by fixed dates but by the readiness and stability of the software. This approach ensures that each version is thoroughly tested and stable.


Software Availability and Package Management (APT): Debian boasts one of the largest software repositories among Linux distributions, with over 59,000 software packages. The Advanced Package Tool (APT) facilitates easy installation, upgrade, and management of these packages.


Community and Support: Debian's global community of developers and users provides extensive documentation, mailing lists, forums, and chat rooms for support and knowledge sharing.


Pros and Cons


Pros:


It is highly stable, making it ideal for server use where uptime is critical.


The vast array of software packages available.


Strong commitment to free software principles.


Cons:


Its focus on stability means newer software versions may take time to be available in the stable release.


It may be less user-friendly for Linux beginners compared to other distributions.


Ideal Use Scenarios for Debian


Debian is best suited for server environments where stability, security, and various software options are paramount. It is an excellent choice for website servers, database servers, and cloud infrastructure.


Additionally, Debian's solid foundation and extensive package repositories make it an ideal platform for developers and those who require a stable system for production environments. Debian offers an unmatched blend of performance and dependability for users who prioritize a system that remains consistent and reliable over time.


Ubuntu


Overview of Ubuntu


Ubuntu is a modern, open-source operating system based on Debian, designed with the user experience in mind. Canonical Ltd. developed it and has gained popularity for its ease of use, robust performance, and strong community support.


Ubuntu aims to offer a reliable and accessible computing experience across various devices, from personal computers to servers and cloud environments.


History and Relationship with Debian


Launched in 2004 by Mark Shuttleworth and his company Canonical, Ubuntu was conceived to build on Debian's architecture and reliability while focusing on user-friendliness and regular release cycles. Ubuntu takes Debian's stable base and adds its own GUI, user-centric features, a predictable six-month release cycle, and Long Term Support (LTS) releases every two years.


Target Audience and Typical Use Cases


Ubuntu's target audience is broad, encompassing new Linux users, desktop users looking for a stable and easy-to-use operating system, developers, and organizations looking for a secure and efficient server OS. It is widely used for web servers and cloud computing, and as a desktop OS, it offers a cohesive experience across various deployments.


Key Features


User-Friendliness and Ease of Use: Ubuntu's graphical user interface (GUI) is intuitive, making it accessible for users transitioning from other operating systems. Including pre-installed software and utilities reduces the need for immediate post-installation setups.


LTS (Long-Term Support) Versions: Ubuntu offers LTS versions that receive all critical security updates and support for five years, appealing to businesses and users seeking stability and long-term reliability.


Ecosystem and Support: Canonical provides professional support and services for Ubuntu, including security updates and patches, making it a solid choice for enterprise environments. The vibrant Ubuntu community also offers extensive documentation, forums, and resources for troubleshooting.


Pros and Cons


Pros:


User-friendly interface ideal for newcomers to Linux.


Consistent release cycle and extensive software compatibility.


Strong support from Canonical, especially for enterprise users.


Cons:


Some users may find the system too resource-heavy for older hardware.


The inclusion of proprietary software in default installations may not align with the ethos of some open-source purists.


Ideal Use Scenarios for Ubuntu


Ubuntu is ideally suited for desktop and server environments, prioritizing ease of use, comprehensive support, and stability. Its desktop version is perfect for users seeking an intuitive and feature-rich OS for personal or professional use.


The server edition is tailored for businesses and developers requiring a stable, secure platform with the option of commercial support for cloud services, web hosting, and application development. Ubuntu's versatility and broad support make it an excellent choice for various computing needs, from casual use to complex enterprise applications.


Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL)


Overview of RHEL


Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL) is a premier, enterprise-focused Linux distribution developed by Red Hat Inc., now part of IBM. RHEL is renowned for its reliability, scalability, and security, making it a preferred choice for many Fortune 500 companies. It supports various hardware platforms and is extensively tested for enterprise environments, ensuring compatibility and performance.


History and Corporate Backing


Red Hat, established in 1993, introduced the Red Hat Linux distribution, which later evolved into RHEL in 2000. This shift marked a strategic focus toward enterprise computing. With the acquisition by IBM in 2019, RHEL has gained even more significant corporate backing, ensuring robust investment in research and development, further enhancing its enterprise capabilities.


Target Audience and Typical Use Cases


RHEL targets large enterprises and data centers requiring a stable, secure, high-performance operating system. It is widely used in finance, government, and healthcare sectors, among others, for critical applications, including database servers, application servers, and virtualization hosts.


Key Features


Enterprise-level Support and Certification: RHEL offers comprehensive support options and certifications with various hardware and software vendors, ensuring seamless integration in complex IT environments.


Stability and Security Features: It is designed for high uptime and reliability, with extensive security certifications like Common Criteria EAL4+ and FIPS 140-2, making it suitable for sensitive and mission-critical deployments.


Subscription Model and Ecosystem: RHEL operates on a subscription model, providing access to Red Hat's software repositories, regular updates, and security patches, along with 24/7 support and consulting services.


Pros and Cons


Pros:


Unmatched enterprise support and a broad ecosystem of partners.


Rigorous security standards and compliance certifications.


High stability and reliability for critical enterprise applications.


Cons:


The subscription model can be costly, especially for small businesses or startups.


The system may be less cutting-edge in terms of adopting the latest software versions compared to other distributions.


Ideal Use Scenarios for RHEL


RHEL is ideal for enterprises that demand the utmost stability, security, and support for their critical IT infrastructure. It is well-suited for financial institutions, government agencies, and any organization that operates in a regulated environment or requires long-term support for their systems. With its extensive testing and certification, RHEL is a top choice for environments where downtime is not an option, such as high-availability servers, database management systems, and large virtualized or cloud infrastructures.


SUSE


Overview of SUSE


SUSE, an acronym for Software und System-Entwicklung (Software and Systems Development), is a global leader in open-source software, providing reliable, interoperable Linux and cloud infrastructure solutions. With a focus on enterprise-grade, scalable solutions, SUSE Linux Enterprise Server (SLES) is designed to support complex workloads across on-premise, cloud, and hybrid environments.


History and Corporate Backing


Founded in Germany in 1992, SUSE is one of the oldest Linux distributions. It has undergone various ownership changes over the years, with notable backing from companies like Novell, Attachmate, and, most recently, EQT Partners. This lineage has provided SUSE with substantial corporate support, fostering a solid foundation for development and growth, especially in the enterprise market.


Target Audience and Typical Use Cases


SUSE is tailored for enterprises seeking a robust, scalable, secure server operating system. It is extensively used in telecommunications, retail, manufacturing, and healthcare industries for running mission-critical applications, including SAP HANA, high-performance computing, and data center operations.


Key Features


YaST (Yet another Setup Tool) for Administration: YaST is SUSE's administration tool, providing a comprehensive graphical interface for system setup, configuration, and management, making it accessible to new and experienced users.


SLES (SUSE Linux Enterprise Server) Features: SLES is designed for stability and security, offering features such as Geo Clustering, Full System Rollback, and support for significant hardware architectures and hypervisors.


Support and Certification: SUSE provides extensive support and certification options, including partnerships with SAP, Microsoft, and VMware, ensuring compatibility and optimized performance across various platforms.


Pros and Cons


Pros:


Exceptional system administration and configuration tool in YaST.


Strong focus on enterprise features, especially for SAP applications and high-availability setups.


Comprehensive support and a wide range of certifications.


Cons:


It may be less popular in the broader community than Ubuntu and RHEL, potentially leading to fewer community-driven resources.


The enterprise support and features pricing model can be a barrier for small to medium-sized enterprises.


Ideal Use Scenarios for SUSE


SUSE is ideally suited for enterprises that require a dependable, secure, and highly scalable operating system for their critical workloads. It excels in environments that demand robust performance and reliability, such as SAP application servers, high-performance computing, and data centers requiring high availability and disaster recovery solutions.


SUSE's administrative tools and enterprise-oriented features make it a preferred choice for organizations looking for a Linux distribution that combines ease of use with comprehensive support and advanced capabilities.


Comparative Analysis


In the Linux server operating systems landscape, Debian, Ubuntu, RHEL, and SUSE each present distinct attributes across performance, stability and reliability, security features, support and community, and cost implications. This comparative analysis highlights how these distributions align with user needs and organizational requirements.


Performance


Debian and Ubuntu are flexible and capable of high performance across various applications, from lightweight servers to desktop computing. In contrast, RHEL and SUSE are specifically tailored for the high demands of enterprise environments, ensuring optimal performance in large-scale, mission-critical deployments.


Stability and Reliability


Debian is celebrated for its exceptional stability, making it a dependable choice for servers that require prolonged uptime. Ubuntu's LTS (Long Term Support) versions offer a stable and supported base that is ideal for business applications. RHEL and SUSE, with their enterprise orientation, undergo extensive testing to guarantee reliability in the most demanding operational contexts.


Security Features


While all four distributions provide comprehensive security features, RHEL and SUSE stand out for their enterprise-grade security certifications and compliance capabilities, catering to sectors with rigorous security and privacy standards.


Support and Community


Debian and Ubuntu boast vast, active communities offering extensive documentation and user forums, which are beneficial for troubleshooting and peer support. On the other hand, RHEL and SUSE offer robust commercial support and services, including guaranteed response times and access to dedicated professionals, which are critical for enterprise users.


Cost Implications


Debian and Ubuntu are freely available, with Ubuntu also offering optional paid support services through Canonical, providing flexibility based on user needs. Conversely, RHEL and SUSE operate on a subscription basis, incorporating both the software and comprehensive support services, which can lead to higher costs but are often justified by the critical nature of the enterprise applications they support.


The choice between Debian, Ubuntu, RHEL, and SUSE should be guided by specific requirements such as stability, security, community support, and budget constraints. Debian and Ubuntu are excellent choices for users seeking robust, community-supported options without the direct cost of commercial support.


Meanwhile, RHEL and SUSE are ideally suited for enterprise environments where the priority lies in obtaining the highest reliability, security, and direct vendor support despite the associated costs. This analysis underscores the necessity of aligning the selection of a Linux server OS with the organization's strategic objectives and operational demands.


Choosing the Right Linux Server OS for Your Needs


Selecting the ideal Linux server or OS requires careful consideration of various factors tailored to your organization's specific needs. The scale of operation, level of technical expertise available, budget constraints, and particular software or hardware requirements all play crucial roles in this decision-making process.


The scale of Operation: For large enterprises with extensive IT infrastructure, RHEL, and SUSE are compelling choices due to their robust support and enterprise-grade stability. Smaller operations or those with less critical requirements might lean towards Debian or Ubuntu for their flexibility and community support.


Technical Expertise: Organizations with a strong IT team prefer Debian for its manual configuration deep customization options and Ubuntu for its user-friendly approach. These suit environments require simplicity and ease of use.


Budget: Debian and Ubuntu, free with optional paid support, are suitable for organizations with limited budgets. In contrast, while more costly, the subscription model of RHEL and SUSE includes comprehensive support and enterprise features that justify the investment for businesses reliant on their IT backbone.


Specific Software or Hardware Requirements: Some distributions may offer better compatibility or optimization for particular applications or hardware. For instance, SUSE is renowned for its excellent support for SAP applications.


Recommendations: Ubuntu or Debian could be ideal for startups and small to medium businesses looking for a balance between functionality and cost. Large enterprises or organizations with critical IT demands might find the investment in RHEL or SUSE more aligned with their operational requirements, offering peace of mind through enterprise-level support and stability.


Conclusion


In conclusion, choosing a Linux server OS, be it Debian, Ubuntu, RHEL, or SUSE, hinges on a nuanced understanding of your organization's specific needs, including operational scale, technical capabilities, budgetary constraints, and specialized requirements.


Each distribution brings unique strengths: Debian and Ubuntu for their community support and flexibility, RHEL and SUSE for their enterprise-grade reliability and security.


By carefully evaluating these factors, organizations can select a Linux server OS that aligns with their current requirements and supports their future growth and evolution, ensuring a robust, secure, and efficient IT infrastructure.




Useful links / Resources


  • What Is Linux? (The Linux Foundation)

  • Linux (WikiPedia)

  • List of Linux distributions (WikiPedia)

  • Debian Linux (Official)

  • Ubuntu Server

  • Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL)

  • SUSE Linux Enterprise Server

  • Fully managed Linux WordPress hosting (Web750)

  • Dedicated servers with choice of Linux OS (Web750)

  • Go back to Web750